My hubby and I have been looking for a NY type of style pizza since we moved to Lancaster 2 years ago. (Yes, we’re from NYC) And ladies & gentlemen this place did NOT disappoint!!! This is as close to NY pizza you will get. Their garlic knots are amazing, the pizza sauce tastes authentic and fresh, wings weren’t crispy like I like them, but they were really good as well!!! I loved it so much, we definitely will become regulars here.

Rivera-Vann Lizsandra

Tried HSP for the first time tonight. Absolutely amazing – garlic knots and the Superior pan pizza. We didn’t think anyone could top Mellow Mushroom but we were wrong! This place and the staff are awesome! Our new #1 pizza joint!

Carla Ford Estridge

So I know we’re late to the party but wow this place is awesome. Amazing pizza and super friendly staff. Thank you!

Craigan Blankenship

Only Fresh
For You

We are all about the love of food and family. Everything
served, from Alfredo sauce to specialty pizzas,